Cannot run Mayer (2015) HP1 benchmarks with available versions

The HP1 code incorporates modules simulating
(1) transient water flow in variably-saturated media,
(2) transport of multiple components, and
(3) mixed equilibrium/kinetic geochemical reactions.
Post Reply
sigda
Posts: 1
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2024 5:44 pm
Location: USA

Cannot run Mayer (2015) HP1 benchmarks with available versions

Post by sigda » Fri Jun 28, 2024 6:09 pm

Hello.
I was pleased to find the Mayer (2015) paper in Computational Geosciences comparing pyrite oxidation scenarios using HP1 and three other codes as I seek simple examples of waste rock leaching for stakeholders involved in a mine closure. I was even more pleased to find the supplementary materials included the model files.

While I am a longtime user of HYDRUS-1D and 2D, I had not run HP1 before. Alas, I can get the example HP1 models to run but not the three benchmark problems using Hydrus-1D version 4.17.0140. HP1 flags the BLOCKDATA section in the PHREEQC.IN files (see output fragment below).

Would you please help me run these files? I suspect there is another version of HP1 that will run these input decks and produce the results shown in the paper.

Thanks and regards,
John Sigda

BEGIN OUTPUT FRAGMENT
DATABLOCK
PhysProp
-headings material ths thr
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -headings material ths thr
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -headings material ths thr
start
1 0.5 0.005
end
MineralProp
-origin 1
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -origin 1
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -origin 1
-headings Name MolarVolume BulkDensity GFW
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -headings Name MolarVolume BulkDensity GFW
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -headings Name MolarVolume BulkDensity GFW
-rowid Name
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -rowid Name
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -rowid Name
start
calcite 36.93339 2.71 100.0894
gypsum 74.1987 2.32 172.1416
pyrite 23.90 5.02 -999
end

Profile
-origin 1
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -origin 1
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -origin 1
-headings materialtype ath
ERROR: Unknown option.
ERROR: -headings materialtype ath
ERROR: Unknown input in RATES keyword.
ERROR: -headings materialtype ath
start

diederik
Posts: 73
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 7:57 am
Location: Belgium

Re: Cannot run Mayer (2015) HP1 benchmarks with available versions

Post by diederik » Mon Jul 01, 2024 7:12 am

Dear,
the correct version of HP was not included in HYDRUS 4.x.
Please contact me directly for more information,

Post Reply